Why Raising Hospital Prices is a Zero Sum Game

In the early 1960s, President John F. Kennedy said, “The time to repair the roof is when the sun is shining.” It was a clarion call, a full-throated warning against national complacency in an era of great prosperity.

It was during this same period that community hospitals stood as the dominant force in American healthcare. By the mid-20th century, some 6,000 inpatient facilities had spread throughout the country, often serving as the financial glue of their respective communities. With well-paying jobs and boards made up of dignitaries, local hospitals aroused a great chorus of civic pride.

But in recent times, the proverbial roof over America’s hospitals has fallen into disrepair. Thanks to operational inefficiencies and declining utilization, more and more hospitals are experiencing financial problems and waning influence.

As health plans, pharmaceutical companies and new care-delivery entrants gain market clout at the expense of the hospital industry, panic is starting to set in. These developments have spurred a recent uptick in hospital mergers, which look more like deals of desperation than long-term growth strategies.

Merger Motives

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) typically serve one of two purposes. The first is to create a more efficient organization. Combining forces can help merged entities weed out redundancy and bolster innovation, resulting in superior products or services at lower prices. The second reason is to build negotiating clout and raise prices.

Most recent hospital mergers, such as the one announced late last year between Dignity Health and Catholic Health Initiatives (CHI), hint at the latter.

Expected to close in the second half of 2018, the agreement would create one of the nation’s largest nonprofit health systems, bringing together 139 hospitals across 28 states with $28.4 billion in revenue. According to a joint press release, the merger represents “an incredible opportunity to expand each organization’s best practices … and deliver high-quality, cost-effective care.”

Indeed, the Dignity/CHI merger could be an opportunity to improve quality and lower costs, but there’s little evidence these financially challenged hospital systems will accomplish either as a combined entity.

In fiscal 2017, Dignity Health experienced a $66.8 million operating loss, worse than in the previous year. Meanwhile, CHI saw operating losses grow from $371.4 million in 2016 to $585.2 million last year. Put these numbers in front of a group of MBA students (or most CEOs working outside the healthcare industry), and they’d all come up with the same M&A strategy: (1) close or combine under-performing facilities, (2) eliminate duplicate clinical services, and (3) reduce administrative overhead.

Instead, Dignity and CHI appear poised to do the opposite. The San Francisco Chronicle reports, “There are no current plans to close any facilities,” and by inference, no job cuts among the health system’s 159,000 employees. Further, the organization announced it will retain co-CEOs, a move that’s almost always more politically expedient than operationally effective.

If the Dignity/CHI merger proves to be less about improving efficiency through consolidation –  more about negotiating higher prices with insurers – they wouldn’t be alone.

Three days before the Dignity/CHI deal was announced, Aurora Health Care, the largest health system in Wisconsin, agreed to combine operations with Advocate Health Care Network, the largest health system in Illinois, a merger that would create the nation’s 10th-biggest nonprofit health system. A week after that, the Wall Street Journal (subscription) reported Ascension Health and Providence St. Joseph Health were in talks to create the nation’s largest hospital chain, with 191 hospitals in 27 states and annual revenue of $44.8 billion.

So far, none of these prospective health systems have demonstrated a willingness to make the hard decisions necessary to improve operational performance.

Hospital CEOs understand it’s much easier to expand clinical services and raise prices than it is to consolidate volume in fewer facilities or demand doctors adopt more efficient practices. And, of course, no CEO wants to be the one to tell a community its local hospital will close.

So, hospitals figure out ways to purchase expensive machines, perform more complex procedures and, ultimately, raise prices.

Why Raising Prices Isn’t The Solution

Raising hospital prices through M&A isn’t a new phenomenon. In 2016, a California-based study found that Dignity Health’s prices were 25% higher ($4,000 more per patient admission) than at other hospitals in the state, a result of Dignity using its market power to demand higher rates. This past November, a California superior court judge ruled that Sutter Health, itself the beneficiary of a 1996 merger, intentionally destroyed evidence in a lawsuit that accused the health system of inflating prices and abusing its market power.

American hospitals have long had the clout to charge whatever they wanted. But today’s purchasers, including the government and major employers, are growing impatient. They’re tired of paying exorbitant rates, especially for services that can be delivered more efficiently elsewhere. Independent “surgicenters” now offer same-day procedures at lower costs than local hospitals. Meanwhile, more patients are being referred to pharmacy-based walk-in clinics rather than going to their local Emergency Room.

Further accelerating the patient migration from U.S. hospitals are moves from insurance giants like United and Humana, which have begun acquiring physician groups, diagnostic facilities, home health practices and other forms of care delivery in bulk.

In a hospital industry that’s heavily dependent on its people, self-disruption will be the only way to lower the cost structure. It will require hospital CEOs to implement more effective approaches for delivering higher-quality care for more patients with less staff in fewer buildings.

Few organizations in any industry find consolidation and downsizing attractive. But the alternative, being disrupted by others, will prove far more painful for hospitals. Unless CEOs are willing to embrace strategies that focus on operational efficiency, their bottom lines will continue to erode as patients pursue more convenient and lower priced care elsewhere.

How To Save America’s Hospitals

Achieving higher-quality, faster access and lower costs are often perceived in healthcare as competing or self-defeating goals. They don’t have to be. In fact, they are necessary steps toward preserving the long-term viability of inpatient facilities. Over the next two months, this series will demonstrate how hospitals can achieve all three.

My next piece will focus on why it is advantageous for hospitals to help patients recover faster and even avoid hospital admissions in the first place. Nationwide, Medicare HMO patients spend an average of 1.6 days in the hospital each year. As CEO of the nation’s largest medical group, I helped Kaiser Permanente facilities reduce that number to 0.7 days per year, less than half national average. I’ll explain how we achieved these results while also improving clinical outcomes.

Nexxt, this series will address issues in the Emergency Department. In 2014, the CDC reported that the average ER wait time is 30 minutes while the average treatment time is 90 minutes. I’ll demonstrate how hospitals can greatly reduce wait times and delays in treatment while reducing costs and the risks imposed on patients.

After that, I’ll focus on the Operating Room, where the time wasted between procedures is responsible for soaring costs for hospitals and worse outcomes for patients.

The final article in the series will put the pieces all together, and propose a model for restructuring the nation’s entire hospital system.

Dr. Robert Pearl is the bestselling author of “Mistreated: Why We Think We’re Getting Good Health Care–And Why We’re Usually Wrong” and a Stanford University professor. Follow him @RobertPearlMD

Why Raising Hospital Prices is a Zero Sum Game published first on https://carilloncitydental.tumblr.com/

Advertisements

Author: BrighterLife

I am a certified Dietitian and won many accolades for my award winning The Nutrition Guide. I am also co-founder of Step Consulting and guiding you to live a healthier you for more than 20 years. I have more than 30 years of work expertise if you are looking for overall wellness and not just about shedding your weight. I have the quality to empower whoever comes in contact with me to take charge of their health and wellbeing. It is all about balance and moderation, with simple concept of eat less and active more. A Master's In Public Health keeps me abreast of the latest health concerns and on the cutting edge of intervention. Focusing on aging and longevity with a holistic approach to living your best life is my pathway to inner peace and happiness.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s